When making cider... We had pressed apples and put juice in a container with a lid (airtight) (forgot about bubbler). Added the yeast after 1 day. Changed the lid on day 2 to one with a bubbler. On day 4, doesn't appear to be any fermentation. Should I be worried? Thanks, Rachel

  • How warm / cold is the fermenter? Check the pack of the yeast for the recommended temperature range. If it's too cold, yeast may go dormant. If it's way too hot, it can die. How do you know there's no fermentation? Bubbles in the airlock are a sign, but you can have fermentation without visible bubbles. Do you have a hydrometer? Take a gravity reading once a day to see if the amount of sugar in the cider changes. Fermentation is done after a few days without change.
    – Robert
    Commented Oct 22, 2020 at 22:10
  • 1
    Thanks all for feedback. We added a little more yeast ( 1 level teaspoon) on day 4 and 1 tablespoon of sugar. Fermentation kicked in within a day. Cider has turned out really well, it's been bottled and we're looking forward to sampling in a month or so.
    – Rachel
    Commented Nov 14, 2020 at 20:53

1 Answer 1


In my experience, I usually don't begin to see CO2 bubbles until days 3 or 4. Usually by the end of a week you should have pretty aggressive fermentation. I usually keep my Cider fermenting on a temperature that is the lowest that the yeast supports on the packet as I find that the fermentation is "cleaner" and I believe yeast will produce more "fusel" alcohols at higher temperatures.

Factors at play

Factors that will affect yeast starting activity are temperature, starter yeast amount, and pitching stress (in decreasing order of impact). If you poured the yeast directly into the cider, the sugar in the juice can cause osmotic stress to the yeast (I recommend gently rehydrating it in a bit of water with a sprinkle of sugar first and I even do this to my baker's yeast for bread). Combine this with very low temperature (50° F) and it could possibly take up to 1.5-2 weeks to see any visible activity.

I have coincidently done "unintentional lambics" by keeping a UV pasteurized fresh pressed honey crisp cider in a very cold garage and I didn't notice fermentation for a while. If you are doing your fermentation at a very low temperature it may take a very long time for it to start. I think if you can't see any activity; Hydrometer readings (as Robert suggested) are probably the only surefire way to see if yeast is converting sugar to alcohol.


In summary, if you are using commercial brewing yeast (hopefully you aren't using baking yeast) you should follow the instructions on the packet, and I recommend brewing at the lowest optimal temperature for the best flavor.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.