I've just primed 4.5L of weissbier with 38g of demerara sugar (the only I had around) and bottled it. According to beersmith's calculator that's what I should add to achieve 3.8 volumes of Co2. After some googling, I gather the values seem to vary a bit, so I'm slightly concerned. Could I be pushing it too much and risking bottle bombs? (I should add that Beersmith was initially giving a 2.3-2.9 for that type of beer but after some googling I've found their range was wrong and updated it to 3.3-4.5.)

  • I think it's a bit much, but bottles should be able to take it
    – slawekwin
    Commented Sep 26, 2016 at 6:15
  • 1
    Some update on this. A month after and no bottle exploded. The beer did come out on the fizzy side but quite drinkable.
    – jpjorge
    Commented Oct 21, 2016 at 18:41

2 Answers 2


It's "only" 8.4 g/L which is IMO is completely fine.

Looks like Beersmith has a more optimistic carbonation formula than most other calcuators.

I find brewers friend one to get close to my expected carbonation (subjectively at least, don't have the means to measure actual level). It gives about 5g/L for 2 volumes, and 8-10g/L for about 3 volumes for sucrose at ale temps.


Last time I brewed a Weissbier, I added ~8g/litre of white table sugar, which seems about the same as your case. My beer turned out somewhat overcarbonated and gushing out on opening when not chilled. However, I think it was far from producing bottle bombs.

As a preventive measure, you might want to make sure the bottles aren't sitting in a too high temperature during bottle conditioning. When you open the first bottle, you'll get a hint regarding the carbonation level. You might want to lift the bottle caps on the remaining bottles and let some of the CO2 out.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.