I came here not only to solve my off-flavour issue, but also to learn more about early stage of fermentation. I am making sodas (mostly Ginger Beer) which I am fermenting for carbonation. Everything went well all winter and I didn't have an issue, but suddenly, two batches in a row, I am smelling and tasting solvent like/nail polish off-flavour. According to the descriptors it seems like it could be ethyl-acetate. The recipe I am using stayed the same, I suppose this could have something to do with the dynamics of the fermentation.

My variables are following: I have a 13 Brix solution made with inverted cane sugar (its taste is part of the drink's signature) and I am pitching it with 2.5g of EC-1118 per 10 litres. What has changed is temperature. In the winter I have put the fermenter in the warmest place in the house (+/- 21 °C), now that the heating is turned off, the temperature has actually dropped to around 17 °C. The fermentation is noticeably slower. The usual 24 hours in the primary produced less froth and the finished soda is less carbonated after similar time in the bottle (i usually pasteurise after 16-20 hours of in-bottle carbonation, staying rather on the safe side)

What seems a little counterintuitive is that most discussions and resources online point to high pitching temperatures as the main culprit. Others say that actually low temperatures actually help the production of esters. One resource hinted me at the concurrence of high metabolism and low growth rate. However my current sugar content should be a piece of pie for the EC-1118, so I wouldn't think this is high SG problem.

Should I just pitch more in lower temps? Or should I avoid lower temps altogether? I have rejected the idea of too much aeration, I doubt the yeast would respire with this much sugar. Am I missing something? Thanks for discussing, I am keen on learning more about the mechanics of the process:-)

2 Answers 2


13 brix / 1.050 SG and 21°C/69°F in a 10liter / 2.6g batch your yeast is going to go nuts leaving almost no residual sugars and make the complex alcohols making the nail polish (solvent-like) off flavor, and a 4-5%ABV "soda" if allowed to complete.

Generally a ginger beer uses a "ginger bug" that ferments just enough to carbonate. Or is stopped by refrigeration or preservative.

Basically that recipe has way to much fermentable sugar and too high of a temperature to keep the growth phase slow.

Rather than using time as a marker for when you stop fermentation, take gravity readings and terminate when you get your 0.5-1%ABV.

Alternatively you can reduce the fermentables then add sugar after pastuerizing.

A "FULL" pitch will skip the growth phase and the need for oxygen. So yes more yeast at lower temp will be much cleaner.

  • 1
    Thanks for your comment, your edit is very helpful! By "skipping the growth phase" you mean that the yeast won't focus on multiplying itself and will rather focus on fermenting? When the yeast grows it breathes, needs oxygen and produces acetate during the process, correct? I have never had issue with getting too much alcohol or fermenting too much of sugar. I always stop the fermentation pretty early. At the recipe's best I was doing 40 hours total. But you are right that hydrometer would be more precise and not depended on temp. murphyandson.co.uk/Datasheets/Yeast%20-%20EC1118.pdf
    – Erik
    Commented May 1, 2017 at 8:31
  • Ethyl acetate is produced during esterifaction which most happens during growth phase. Slowing or limiting growth reduces overal esters. Or best in your case pitch big to get to feeding sooner skipping most of the growth. Commented May 1, 2017 at 13:38

Agree with Evil Zymurgist 100% but wanted to emphasize something. I've never heard that lower fermentation temps will encourage ester production. Also, definitely use a hydrometer for any level of precision. Forty hours is enough time to ferment a significant percentage of your sugars. I'd be willing to bet you've probably been getting a higher alcohol content than you've been assuming.

  • Thanks for your comment! I have read about the low temp Ester production here: vintessential.com.au/resources/articles/… . About the hydrometer use: if I leave some part of the ferment open for taking readings, will I be able to apply them to the ferments in the bottle as well? Or is the speed going to be different?
    – Erik
    Commented May 5, 2017 at 0:26
  • I will definitely read that article. Thanks for sharing it! As far as your hydrometer question, the answer is that the speed would be the same, assuming that they both have the same concentration of fermentable sugars, are kept at the same temp, and are otherwise identical.
    – thekolnik
    Commented May 5, 2017 at 13:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.