I'm still pretty new to home brewing, so I'm sure I made about a hundred mistakes with this beer. I brewed a 1.079 OG imperial porter, and used Safale 05 (only one pack, unfortunately). First of all, I think I under-pitched the yeast, and then I only kept it in primary for seven days. I tasted it during racking, and there were definitely some pretty distinct fruity flavors there that I did not expect or want. The gravity read 1.032, so I assumed I did not have enough yeast for that big of a beer, and the yeast got really stressed out, hence the fruit. I added 1.70 cups of bourbon, an ounce of oak chips, and three cut-up vanilla beans at secondary, as per the recipe that I found. Since the gravity was still so high, I repitched into secondary with a new pack of 05, hoping that would kick-start more fermentation and get the gravity down to 1.017 where it's supposed to be. After four days, there is barely any activity in the airlock, so I don't think it's fermenting. Is there any hope for this beer turning out, or for those fruity flavors to disappear? I'm also concerned about leaving it in secondary with the oak chips and vanilla beans for too long. Could someone please point me in the right direction?

  • 1
    Leave it on what little yeast cake you currently have now for at least two weeks. Then take a sample and taste it. If its still fruity, you can make a simple pint starter or wort and half a pack of yeast. Once its really awake and going (8 hours) pitch the whole thing in there the active yeast will scavenge some of the fruit.
    – brewchez
    Apr 11, 2012 at 22:20
  • 3
    Bit of advice, if you are new to brewing, then doing a "1.079 OG imperial porter" with bourbon, oak and vanilla beans is just too ambitious for you. Heck, I've made over 50 batches myself and I'd consider that beer ambitious. Start with a normal porter, and brew it a few times to perfect your process, then start experimenting with it.
    – GHP
    Apr 12, 2012 at 12:57
  • Also, do NOT rack ANYTHING after 7 days. You might have stalled out the yeast by doing this. Leave your stuff in primary for 2-3 weeks before TOUCHING IT and you'll make better beer.
    – GHP
    Apr 12, 2012 at 12:57
  • Graham, I disagree about staying in primary for two to three weeks. Many routine recipes are improved by getting your beer into secondary. Once fermentation is primarily complete (low activity), there is more benefit to getting off the yeast cake than to leaving it in primary. Sitting on the yeast cake can result in off flavors from autolyzation. Apr 12, 2012 at 15:38
  • Keith, what you are stating was the standard lore of homebrewing for decades, but has been pretty much thoroughly refuted. It might be better quality yeast that's now making the difference. Both Jamil Z and John Palmer recommend primaries of 2 weeks to a month for normal beers. Lagers, fruit beers, very high gravity beers and maybe sours are the only beer that really benefit from secondaries.
    – GHP
    Apr 12, 2012 at 20:50

2 Answers 2


The fruitiness will reduce over time, espeically in big beer like that which can take a year or more to reach maturity, by which time the esters will definitely have lessened, so don't give up on this one just yet.

Pitching dry yeast directly into secondary with a high alcohol content will lead to a poor fermentation. It will probably pick up eventually, but may need 3-5 days to get going. Next time, rehydrate the yeast first, and ideally make a small starter and pitch when at high krausen. This gives the yeast the necessary kickstart to get fermentation of the bigger beer going.

Unfortunately, little or lack of air-bubbles doesn't always mean no fermentation - best to take a gravity reading every couple of weeks to know for sure. US05 is hardy and works down to fairly low temps, but even so, raise the temperature to 65-68F if it's below that to give the yeast some extra help.

You may also want to try a forced ferement, to find out what the actual FG for this brew is. Then you know exactly what you're aiming for.

As a new brewer, you're bound to be anxious about the brew and curious to find out how things are doing. One of the best tools available is time, which can fix many problems, especially with the big beers! Take a gravity reading in a couple of weeks and I'm fairly confident you'll see the gravity falling.

  • Assuming this is Denny's BVIP, he recommends drinking it young and not aging it. Even if I wanted to age it, I'm not sure I could. It's too good young.
    – Ell
    Apr 13, 2012 at 14:17

There are a couple of things that you can do to prevent the esters from occurring in your next brew

  • Hydrate your dried yeast according to the instructions before pitching
  • Use Mr Malty to calculate the correct amount of yeast to pitch
  • Control your ferment temperature. US-05 will produce very few esters at 18C or 64-65F

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.