I have successfully made several (at least 15) gallons of homemade wine, and only really had one come out undrinkable (was black cherry experiment, made a decent cooking wine) I started with a simple balloon and welches set up, amazed it worked, and got hooked.

I digress...

So I have been playing with different sugar contents, how much alcohol I could get vs over sweet, and in general just playing. It always seems to work for the most part. Using gallon glass jugs, 4 going this time.

Some of these batches have active bubbled and foamed for 4+ weeks, average temp 74°F and never shot higher than 19% ABV. I have used everything from grocery store bread yeast to Lavlin EC-1118. Stays active, tastes great, on average goes pretty dry and high alcohol. After it goes clear and settles, degas, bottled, and drank a couple months later.

Most everything I read though [about fermentation duration] states like days, or maybe couple of weeks max.

So I figured I would start getting some more experienced advice, and see what I am really dealing with. maybe start thinking smarter not harder.

I have tried with and without yeast nutrient (Fermax), which seems to make it more aggressive but last just as long and no appreciable difference in end product.

So if someone could nudge me in the correct direction on what to expect or do differently, all info welcome, and thank you.

Pear, Blueberry, and two Apples

  • If I understand the question, you think that your wine is fermenting for too long, like 4+ weeks?
    – Philippe
    Commented Nov 7, 2019 at 13:05
  • Correct, it always seems to come out fine, but seems to take much longer than what seems to be average in recopies and information I am reading. Trying to understand why, or if it is normal to fluctuate that much (also why)
    – Sabre
    Commented Nov 7, 2019 at 14:08

1 Answer 1


You have to use an hydrometer to measure gravity if you want to know what is going on. Foam and airlock bubbling activity is not a precise indication of an active fermentation. Measure gravity before fermentation, and then every 3 days. Usually, 3 days in a row of stable gravity means fermentation is done (or stuck!).

When fermentation is done, there is still CO2 in the liquid that is released slowly, giving the impression of an active fermentation. Since you degas your wine, you already know that.

The speed of fermentation depends on many factors, like yeast cell count, temperature, pH, yeast nutrients, quantity of sugar, presence of oxygen, yeast alcohol tolerance...

If you ferment close to 19% ABV, you might have reached the yeast alcohol tolerance threshold, and at that point it will slow down and eventually stop working. You can use a yeast that has an higher alcohol tolerance, but 19% is already pretty high, although some can go up to 25%.

If you maintain a stable temperature of 74°F (23°C), it is the ideal temperature for most yeast. Check the yeast package for ideal range, the hotter the faster. But a faster fermentation might produce a different taste in the final product, you must be aware of that.

Most fruits juice already have sufficient natural yeast nutrients and you don't need to add more. Fermenting sugar only or mead, will requires the addition of nutrients. If fermetation starts within a day, it most probably doesn't need additional nutrients.

I rarely measure pH, mostly because I make the same beer/wine over and over, but if you try new fruits/recipe, you maybe should because:

The optimum pH for most micro-organisms is near the neutral point (pH 7.0). Moulds and yeasts are usually acid tolerant and are therefore associated with the spoilage of acidic foods. Yeasts can grow in a pH range of 4 to 4.5 and moulds can grow from pH 2 to 8.5, but favour an acid pH (Mountney and Gould, 1988).

If you buy fruit juice, make sure it doesn't contain sulfites or sorbate, because they will slow down fermentation.

Some more information about stuck fermentation.

There are many questions here on SE about fermentation, give the search a try and you will find a lot of information.

  • Thank you, they are all organic juices, no additives preservative, or added sugars. I take a hydrometer reading and then add sugar until it reaches a little under what I am aiming for then cool and check again to make sure I got it close enough to correct. So if I gather that correctly, the lack of clarity/settling, is just likely excess CO2 still coming out, and I can save the time to just sample and not wait for it to settle if the gravity is correct? Will the high CO2 throw off the hydrometer reading (Like should I shake out the sample before reading?)
    – Sabre
    Commented Nov 7, 2019 at 14:19
  • People usually, make the hydrometer spin to remove some CO2 that could attach to it. Degassing the sample could also work. After fermentation there is always a phase of stabilisation, where yeast and sediments will flocculate to the bottom. It is normal to wait for the wine to clarify, even if the fermentation is usually done after 1-2 weeks.
    – Philippe
    Commented Nov 7, 2019 at 14:37
  • 1
    I did read that high CO2 concentrations will actually make the solution weigh a little heavy, so I tested both theories. I poured off a little of one of the sample, still bubbling but starting to clarify some. It went to almost dry before degas (and had fizz equivalent to strong soda), and damn near completely dry after shaking in a mason jar 'till it fizzed no more. I was still getting a bubble every 20-30 seconds out of that bottle on the airlock. So lesson learned, bubbles, even if frequent mean CO2 left over not sugar. Gravity wins, TY much. Will be racking this weekend.
    – Sabre
    Commented Nov 7, 2019 at 23:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.