I currently have a stout (my 2nd home brew) in a secondary fermentor (glass carboy). Once it reaches FG, what are the advantages/disadvantages of leaving it in the secondary to condition vs bottling right away (or FG + x days)? Obviously, the secondary buys me time to empty enough bottles but is there any impact to the beer (assuming it ages the same amount of time prior to consumption)? If I wait too long will the bottles take too long to condition? If I bottle too soon do I lose any benefits of the secondary?


  • I ended up bottling after 3 weeks in secondary. After one week was decently carbonated, at two weeks, little difference from the first. Tastes wonderful; looking forward to brewing my first AG in the next couple weeks. Going forward will probably bottle sooner (or maybe keg... Santa, you listening?) so I can enjoy my beer sooner.
    – Mr D
    Sep 7, 2010 at 22:02

1 Answer 1


Leaving it in the secondary will allow more sediment to settle out of the beer, but eventually this isn't going to matter too much. After a while your returns will diminish indefinitely, and with a stout I wouldn't worry about it as it isn't supposed to be a nice clear beer. If you wait a long time, like a matter months then the yeast will lose vitallity and it will take longer to carbonate in the bottle, but I wouldn't too much about a few weeks. I would just bottle it when you are ready and enjoy emptying those bottles that the stout is going to be in. In general, the secondary fermenter can hold a beer longer when you want it to clear up nicely, but with stouts and wheat beers especially, I just bottle when I'm ready and don't allow them to settle too much. I once got lazy and left a heffeweizen in the secondary for six months and it cleared up beautifully! It was so clear and golden it looked fantastic, however, it looked nothing like the heff I was going for. If you bottle your stout in the next couple of weeks I don't see any difference in the benefits of letting it sit in the secondary or the bottle.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.