After 20 years of fermenting in glass carboys, I recently dove in and bought a Blichmann Fermenator. I Scrubbed it according to the docs that came with it, and then gave it my usual BTF soak and air dry before brewing with it.

The first batch had a pretty godawful metallic or.. I don't really know how to classify it... harsh smell after 1 week in primary. Same recipe I had just brewed successfully a month prior, sans the funky smell. After a week I dumped trub, dry hopped for 2 weeks of secondary. The smell remained. It's not a spoilage smell-- after sharing it with other homebrew geeks we all agree it's not an infection smell. It's pretty astringent, slightly metallic, maybe somewhat chemical. Though my mash was only at 150º so I shouldn't have extracted tannins to give astringency. The beer tastes fine, not great.

Anyway, when I popped the lid after 3 weeks, there was a layer of black scum on the sides of the fermenator just above the krausen ring. Oily. Not green or white like most mold. The beer itself looked like... well... beer.

I ended up dumping the batch and brewing again. This new batch has remnants of that smell, but not quite as bad. It was a long road to get here, but here's the question, at long last:

is there something I need to know about fermenting in steel? Does this funky smell blow off once it gets to glass or gets carbonated? Or was I blowing it off before by racking/oxygenating and just never got to smell my beer at this stage?

1 Answer 1


I thought I read on another forum the exact same problem with this product. I think I remember its a finish that is put on the metal during fabrication.

I'd call blichmann directly to straighten it out. They are a stand up group and stand behind their products.

  • 1
    Yep, it's oil. Talked to Blichmann and they were very helpful. Apparently they had a batch of oily valves and notified their customers (stores) about it, but my brew shop hadn't gotten the word. You have to disassemble the valves and soak them in acetone to get the oil out. Going to do so tomorrow and then brew again, so will update this post if that resolved the issue.
    – Juanote
    Commented Jul 17, 2010 at 4:22
  • 3
    Soaking the valves in acetone followed by a good cleaning with PBW and a sanitizer soak did the trick. Bottled a batch of IPA tonight.
    – Juanote
    Commented Jul 31, 2010 at 4:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.