I haven't been able to sort out the exact differences, it seems to me both of them are blended with yeast in a 'must' for x number of days then bottled for secondary fermentation/carbonation. What am I missing? Of course that's stripping it down to the bare minimum, variations exist; beer often includes hops along the way, white wine grapes are peeled beforehand, etc., but is there a fundamental difference?

Also, from what I understand, sake and cider are made the same way as wine. Cider makes more sense to me as it is also a fruit, but rice (the base of sake) is a cereal grain just like barley/wheat, so does that imply barley could be brewed the same way as sake or wine as well? What would that taste like? Is there a name for it?

1 Answer 1


IMHO the most discernible difference between beer and wine is the use of grain and grapes/fruit. Beer tends to be grain based - think Reinheitsgebot. However it can be difficult to decide if cider is a beer or a wine - maybe a fruit beer? Carbonation per se seems to be no guide, as champagne is fizzy - more so than most beers. Use of hops seems to be peculiar to beer - but there are reports of one or two wines made with hops. So that may be a good indication but is not a defining factor. Most beers have added yeast and most natural wines are fermented with the yeast naturally on the grapes. But with modern industrial processes that tends to be lost in mass production methods that add yeast to both brews.

I suppose the obvious defining factor of "beer" is that it is made from malted and mashed grain. The sugars need to be converted from the starch stored in the grain to be able to ferment. That conversion might define the brew as beer. Wines are made from things that already have fermentable sugar and so no conversion is needed. That definition would make cider an "apple wine" and sake a "rice beer".

Barley in its dry stored state has little if any natural sugar that can be fermented by yeast to produce alcohol. It has to be malted and mashed for the sugars to be converted ready for fermentation. Could one polish barley grains and then treat them with Aspergillius mold like rice? Err, possibly but why?

Sake is made from unmalted rice grain. The startch in the polished rice grain is converted to fermentable sugars with the help of Aspergillus mold. Then the fermentation to produce alcohol is done with Saccharomyces. So one might say sake is like beer as the rice must be "prepared" to ferment.

  • 2
    In it's essence, it is simple to think of it as grapes left to their own devices can become wine. Grain cannot.
    – andy
    Commented Aug 1, 2017 at 12:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.