14

Back when I started homebrewing, I used a Pur filter. I've since moved and my kitchen sink won't accept any sort of filter. I've brewed a few batches with just Fairfax County, VA tap water, and not noticed any real difference.

I was wondering what the consensus is: Do you use tap water? Filter with a faucet-mounted filter? Filter with a pitcher type filter? Pre-boil water?

Sub-question: Take the water as you get it (whether filtered or tap), or add minerals and whatnot?

13

Most tap water (in America) is good for brewing

I recommend removing (filtering) or adding things to your water only if you have a problem with it. (Or want to create a beer with a historic profile, like Burton on Trent, Pilsen, or Dublin.)

Your water influences a few things in the brewing process, namely the mash and the overall product. When evaluating which water to use, ask yourself some questions.

  1. How does it taste? Do I notice anything off about may water? (EG: chloramines, sodium)
  2. If my tap water tastes funny, does the flavor carry over to the resultant beer?
  3. Am I getting good efficiency and conversion in my mash?

My answers were:

  1. Icky. Tastes like salt.
  2. Hard to tell.
  3. No, my efficiency is crap

Turns out the water in my area is crap for brewing.

Water-influenced flavor problems

Try purchasing spring water or filtering your water. If you mash or mini-mash do not use distilled or reverse-osmosis water. I built this cheap filter that should be good for about 770 ten-gallon batches.

Simple water filter

Mash problems

Poor efficiency could be caused by water chemistry. The mash needs to reach a low pH for optimal enzyme activity. Minerals in the water may prevent it from reaching 5.0-5.6 pH and filtering generally does not help with this. Obtain your local water report. It should be available on your water company's web site, or search "water report" and the name of your town/city and state.

Some qualities, like too much of a problematic mineral, can be solved by diluting with RO water. In rare occasions, like mine, you have to build your water from scratch. This is a good motivator to learn the necessary water chemistry related to brewing. It's beyond the scope of this question, so I won't go into it here.

  • For drinking & cooking I use a under-the-counter reverse osmosis filter. Not cheap and doesn't have the capacity for 10 gallon batches, but takes care of the problem. – Dean Brundage Mar 25 '10 at 22:27
4

I've always just used my tap water, but I know a guy who takes his carboy to Kroger and just sticks it in the water cooler refilling station, and he says it's pretty cheap.

  • about $.50/gal at safeway....but this water will have NO MINERAL NUTRIENTS.....something to think about. – Arlo427 Mar 24 '10 at 15:19
  • It's not deionized is it? – Room3 Mar 24 '10 at 17:46
  • Isn't that water the same as your tap water, just run through a filter? – Room3 Mar 24 '10 at 17:54
  • 1
    Some of the spring waters will have minerals, likely very low concentrations. You can probably find the report on the supplier's web site. – Dean Brundage Mar 25 '10 at 22:25
1

You can buy a sink filter for under a $100. In the long run it turns out to be cheaper than Brita filters and faucet-mounted filters. So easy to install.

  • "In the long run it turns out to be cheaper than Brita filters." How do you figure? You're encouraged to replace the charcoal in Brita filters because after a while they accumulate germs. You can absolutely detect this: if you keep a Brita filter way too long the water comes out smelly. Why would an in-line sink filter be any different? – DanielSank Aug 1 '14 at 8:18
1

I use filtered water (under-counter job with a separate faucet, about $80 from Home Depot), because my public water is disgustingly bleachy. They tell me it's within spec of chlorine PPM, but it's truly awful. Smells like a sanitizing solution.

Filtered Water Kit http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_Yq49vDkFRvI/Rs-kESnYwSI/AAAAAAAAAB0/iw01DxIK1QU/s1600-h/KitchenAfter4.jpg

Well water can have a whole different set of issues. Where I used to live, I had a ton of manganese and iron from a well, so I had to Brita that to make it potable.

If your water doesn't taste "off" you're probably fine, but like Dean said, there are definitely options for playing with water chemistry, especially if you're trying to replicate a regional style.

1

It depends on where you are getting your water from. Here in the Seattle area, we get our water from mountain reservoirs and we have very low mineral content which is good place to start and easy to add the minerals you want. If you live in a place like Arizona, where they mostly pump the water out of underground reservoirs and tastes like crap, you will either want a Reverse Osmosis filter or a go down to Safeway and use the filtering station. Make sure to check your local water report which are usually available from your water supplier.

Reverse Osmosis Filter:

https://www.amazon.com/APEC-5-Stage-Reverse-Drinking-Water/dp/B00I0ZGOZM

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.