0

Is there a preferred beer style for making malt vinegars? Has anybody experimented with using different styles of beer to make vinegar and what types of results were experienced.

2

To my knowledge there is no preferred beer style that is preferred for making malt vinegar - it is just that it can be brewed from malt. No hops are added to malt solutions used for fermenting, for example so it would be difficult to call the base liquor a "beer". Traditionally beer per se is not usually used for making vinegar. "Vin gar" bad wine is usually the traditional source of making vinegar (eg balsamico) although I accept ciders and fruit brews are also frequently used.

The modern practice is to infect a sterile sugar solution with yeast and then acetobacter and let it ferment to make acetic acid. That is distilled out to make more concentrated acetic acid which is diluted and flavoured in various ways. Modern "Malt" vinegar is usually flavoured and coloured with caramel. It can certainly be made or flavoured with malt extract (as the name suggests) but it isn't the usual method. Except perhaps its accidental use by home-brewers desperate to find a use for another spoilt brew! :0) Malt has largely been replaced with corn/maize sugar due to lower cost.

4
  • I think you meant add a mixed culture of yeast and acetobacter to a sugar solution, Acetobacter will oxidise ethanol to acetic acid, but can't metabolise sugars. There's a thread on the subject here homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=464480. I like the suggestion of making malt vinegar from the spent wort of a yeast starter. – Kevin Sharp Jul 25 '16 at 22:49
  • I agree yeast is added. An important but missing detail. Edited answer to include the yeast addition. – barking.pete Jul 26 '16 at 22:22
  • Accepted, but only because there is a lack of information/research generally available on this topic. There are people starting to experiment with different beer types (malt styles, w/ and w/o hops), but limited published results. One addition, hops don't appear to be present in malt vinegars. And, most mainstream commercial processes are very different than how a homebrewer might approach them as indicated above. – Jim Rush Aug 26 '16 at 21:47
  • 1
    I have heard comments that hop flavoured vinegar is not to everyone's taste as it can be bitter. The hops can also act as a natural antibiotic meaning the fermentation by acetobacter may not proceed as planned. It would be an interesting experiment to "dry hop" some commercial malt vinegar and see how the taste was changed. One might get a hop flavoured/aroma vinegar in the fashion of balsamico.If one wanted to start with a beer base then one might try a lambic - naturally malty and brewed slightly sour by using natural yeast and wild bacteria. – barking.pete Aug 28 '16 at 9:16
2

I own and operate a vinegar company:

Beer style certainly effects the process and outcome of fermented vinegar. Vinegar bacteria is as unique as your environment, some strains being more aggressive or tolerable than others.

Preference with style is only dependent on how much home-brew you may mess up or what your desired end-flavor may be. Lighter beers ferment out with lower acidity due to their generally lower alcohol levels. Reds, browns and doubles can ferment out to be your average dry vinegar with great acidity. Strong ales or boozy beers can ferment out with acidity with residual sugars to balance the flavor.

Its best to understand vinegar fermentation as if you were fermenting wort. But when using aceto-bacter (AB), your fuel is alcohol, not sugar. Try fermenting a 5 Gallon LME to 4 gallons water with some basic 001. Let it go for 2 weeks, transfer to a vessel that allows breathing but is covered with cheese cloth. You will need a proven AB inoculation. 3 months later you'll have vinegar (assuming 65 to 90 degrees). Keep in mind lots of off flavors are produced through the process but it ultimately cleans out to great aroma.

Vinegar is like a college student, it loves: dark, warmth, alcohol and air

Stay SOUR!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.