What tools for measuring specific gravity are available to the homebrewer? EG: refractometer, hydrometer.

What scale do they measure? EG: Brix, plato

Since there hasn't been much activity on the question, this is what I'm looking for. Any more comprehensive answers?

  • Hydrometer measures Specific Gravity
  • Refractometers are usually scaled in % Brix
  • Bottles measure Specific Gravity
  • I haven't seen SG bottles sold by any homebrew store or online homebrew store, so doubt they're in wide usage. Maybe this question would be better rephrased as "What advantages of refractometers over hydrometers would justify the cost?" (Delete this comment at will.) – Rich Armstrong Mar 8 '10 at 16:18
  • You have a refractometer, I think I read somewhere. Tell us why you like it! :) – Rich Armstrong Mar 8 '10 at 16:18
  • I like it because it takes a small sample size. I don't like that it reads in % Brix because everything is formulated for SG or ºP. I'm not looking for a replacement for my hydrometer. – Dean Brundage Mar 9 '10 at 1:20
  • All I want to know is exactly what I asked in the question. Don't need a comparison or to know how they work. Simply interested if there is something out there beyond the two standard SG tools. – Dean Brundage Mar 13 '10 at 13:29

When you are measuring the specific gravity, you want to know the weight of a specific volume of liquid. This being said, the refractometer is not strictly speaking a tool to measure the specific gravity. It does measure the refractive index of the liquid. Assuming that you deal with water plus sugar, you can calculate the quantity of sugar from the refractive index, and from this, the specific gravity, so it is really an indirect measurement.

To directly measure the density of a liquid, you can put a precise amount of liquid in a graduated cylinder and weight it to directly get the density of the liquid. However, this is not very convenient as it is often difficult to measure the volume precisely because of the meniscus on the side of the tube. In addition, you need a precise graduated cylinder, a precision scale and maybe a pipette, which is not very convenient. A way to do so precisely is with a pycnometer what you call a "bottle to measure specific gravity". You still need a precision scale though

Using Archimedes principle is in the end the most convenient way to measure gravity, as it can be done with a single, inexpensive tool, the hydrometer. So you mentioned the main tools already.

Regarding units, tools that measure density or specific gravity will either give results in g/cm^3 or as a uniteless ratio of the density of the liquid over some reference liquid (such as water). One could argue that hydrometer give a result in °P, but this is not exactly true. Hydrometer directly measure the density of the liquid, but because they are mostly used in brewing or wine making, you find them with a °P scale, so you don't have to make the conversion (although we often do it backwards to go back to specific gravity from the °P result).

Now they are other methods to measure the density of fluid, but they are often hardly available to brewers. You can use ultrasonic waves to infer the density (as speed of sound in a material depends on this parameter). You can also do it by measuring the pressure inside a column of liquid as a function of depth, etc.

| improve this answer | |

Typically a Hydrometer measures (or at least mine measures) Specific gravity, potential alcohol, and/or Balling. Refractometers measure Brix.

Most beer recipes use SG as their measurement. For example, according to NorthernBrewer, their California Common kit has an OG of 1.047. Hypothetically if you were to measure an amount of pure water (just H-O-H) at the calibration temperature (typically somewhere around 60F-70F), you would get 1.000. Warmer liquids are not as dense, therefore the same volume of pure water at 150F would be much lower. Similarly, that same sample of pure water at 35F would be much more dense.

Refractometers? I'm sorry I never owned one, so I can't speak about them other than they are significantly expensive and that since your sample is 3-4 drops of liquid, and not 3-4 liquid ounces... temperature is not much of an issue, and the degrees of Brix measures the amount of sugar, and there IS a conversion from Brix to SG, but I don't know it.

| improve this answer | |
  • Looking for a more comprehensive answer. – Dean Brundage Feb 24 '10 at 13:23
  • H<sub>\<sub>O</sub>/</sub>H :D – JackSmith Feb 24 '10 at 13:45
  • More comprehensive and more simple. – Dean Brundage Feb 25 '10 at 4:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.