I have a barleywine in progress that seems to have stalled around 9% ABV with some residual sweetness I'd like to try and reduce. After 2.5 weeks in primary all activity had stopped so I racked off to fresh fermentor. Two more weeks with agitation and SG hasn't really fallen any more.

I'm thinking of pitching Safale US-05 to see if it can drop it a few more SG points. I've found little advice on how to prepare yeast for such a toxic environment. This comment in a post about preparing a starter argues it's a pointless exercise as only 'unhealthy' yeast will result from highly alcoholic environments. Sounds a bit wonky to me - I'd expect unhealthy yeast to die and the survivors to be more resilient..

My own idea would be to rehydrate as usual in ~25°C water for ~15 mins, then slowly add barleywine over another 30 mins or so to gradually bring it up to 9% before pitching. Seems more likely to give them a chance to adapt than by pitching straight from being rehydrated.

All views on this from those with relevant experience very much appreciated.

Edit: Details of (slightly experimental) recipe. Batch ~15L approx - all quantities are estimates as I used the parti-gyle split method..

Mash - 60 mins @ 67°C (target temps hit)

  • 5.0 kg Marris Otter Pale
  • 0.2 kg Crystal 120

Boil additions

  • 0.1 kg roasted barley ('tea' from cold steep)
  • 0.5 kg light DME

Nottingham yeast

OG 1.083 | FG 1.016

1 Answer 1


No worries...05 will perform fine without anything special. Rehydrate it for best performance and then just toss it in. I've gone to 12% ABV with it with no issues. But my question is, how do you know it's the yeast? Why isn't it a fermentability of wort issues? Tell us more about your recipe and procedure in order to help figure out what's going on.

  • Thanks Denny. Recipe details added. Any comments?
    – geotheory
    Jul 27, 2015 at 16:58
  • OK, I don't see a lot of unfermentables there in terms of ingredients. The extract will be to some extent, but there's not a lot of that. Nottingham should have no trouble at all dealing with a 1.083 beer. However, since the gravity hasn't fallen further, I really suspect that fermentation is done. I also think that's a fine FG for a 1.083 beer. Is there some particular reason you want it lower or think it should be?
    – Denny Conn
    Jul 27, 2015 at 19:32
  • One thing you can do is try a fast ferment test (sometimes called a forced ferment test). That will tell you is it's the wort or the yeast. Take a sample and put it in a container like a jar. Add a LOT of yeast to it...it can even be bread yeast. All we want to do is find out how low that wort will ferment. Leave it in a warm place for a few days, then take a reading again. If it's dropped, you know there's still fermentation to be done. If it hasn't, the beer is finished.
    – Denny Conn
    Jul 27, 2015 at 19:32
  • Hmmm, yeah maybe it is done. It is still a bit sweet though, although perhaps that'll reduce after 3 months conditioning. I've pitched the 05 anyway to see if there's any effect.
    – geotheory
    Jul 27, 2015 at 21:16
  • 1
    Keep in mind that sweetness can be as much due to lack of hops as fermentation. Also, alcohol adds sweetness, so stronger beers will seem sweeter.
    – Denny Conn
    Jul 28, 2015 at 15:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.