0

I was just experimenting with the 'Brew It!' tool on Brewers' Friend and the instructions say that for a 12 litre boil, I should add 8.8 litres to the kettle along with 5kg of dry malt extract which equates to a further 3.2 litres totaling 12L - my target volume.

I'm going to reasonably assume that Brewers' Friend knows it's stuff but I have always taken the boil volume to be the water only!

Have I been doing it wrong?

For the purposes of future brewing and consistency should I just adjust my recipe so the pre boil water volume reads 12L?

Improve this question
  • Is 12 liters the volume you want in your kettle after mashing or the volume you want in your fermenter? – Atron Seige Jul 15 '15 at 12:59
  • 24l is my desired fermentation volume. The 12L I specified was 12L of water to bring to the boil then add 3.2L of malt, totaling 15.2L. I would then top up the wort with another 9 or so litres to reach my target of 24L – Phizzy Jul 15 '15 at 13:10
3

It it dry or liquid malt extract? Dry malt extract will dissolve into the water, leading to a minimal volume change, whereas liquid malt extract still has a substantial portion of water, and will have somewhat like the volume change you describe, though I don't believe it's quite 1:1.

In short, your boil volume should be the boil volume. With dry extract, that does not include the negligable "volume" of the extract. With liquid extract, that will include some portion of the volume of the extract.

Improve this answer
  • I am using dry malt extract only. I was working on the malt powder displacing an amount of water equal to its volume... You said it dissolves which I guess makes sense. It has what, 3% moisture content? So if I leave a bit of room in my boil pot to allow for a small increase in volume + hot break etc. I should be fine? Thanks!! – Phizzy Jul 15 '15 at 14:42
  • Ideally your boil kettle would be 50% larger than your pre-boil volume, mostly to account for boil-over. The volume difference from thermal expansion of the water/wort is minimal but non-trivial, but the boiling head and boil-over is the bigger concern by far. I regularly have a 12gl pre-boil volume in my 15.5gl keggle, and I watch it like a hawk as it comes to a boil to prevent boil-over. – jsled Jul 15 '15 at 18:19
  • Hi Jsled, as an update to this - I brewed last night and the DME ended up taking up approx. 1L per kg in the pan. I had to split the boil up into 2 pans as not to compromise on my boil size. As this goes against your answer, 1) Should I post this as another answer? 2) I don't doubt your own answer/experience, possibly our DME was of a different brand/type? – Phizzy Jul 17 '15 at 14:17
  • You should doubt my answer, with direct evidence to the contrary in front of you! :) – jsled Jul 17 '15 at 14:46
  • 1
    I won't trust you again in the future then! ;) Thanks again! – Phizzy Jul 17 '15 at 15:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.