What's the pros and cons about mash in coolers or pots? How to choose?

  • Chino tells the pros and cons listed as I asked, so I'm accepting his very good answer. But Denny's experience sharing was also very important to me to buy a cooler and give it a try. Thanks you both.
    – jards
    Commented Oct 6, 2014 at 16:39

2 Answers 2


Cooler as Mash Tun

Pros: Relatively cheap and easy to modify with a bulkhead fitting and ball valve. Holds a steady temperature very well. Lighter weight, and therefore easier to clean.

Cons: Cannot be direct-fired, so any step mashing has to be done with additional infusions or by decoction - step infusions will increase your mash's water-to-grist ratio. Will not perform double duty as a kettle (but can be used for cold beverages).

Kettle as Mash Tun

Pros: Can be direct-fired for stepped mash schedules. Can be used in advanced homebrewing setups such as RIMS or HERMS systems. Can double as a kettle.

Cons: Higher cost. The kettle is not insulated, so it is harder to maintain a steady temperature. More difficult to modify to add a ball valve. Heavier, and therefore harder to clean, relatively speaking.

How to choose?

It comes down to your budget and personal preference.


I have used a cooler for 466 batches over the last 17 years. I have tried using a pot to mash in and found I preferred the cooler because it held the temp so well. I seldom find a need to do step mashes and in fact question their value. But when I want to do one, it's a simple matter to simply infuse boiling water until I get to the temp step I'm going for. You can see my equipment and methods at www.dennybrew.com

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.