I have ordered around 16 extract batches from Northern Brewer. I've noticed a trend in the time the instructions ask you to wait before bottling: if the OG is greater than 1.050, bottle after four weeks, and less than 10-50, bottle after two weeks.

For the higher OG ones, the instructions seem to always call for a secondary fermentation. I have stopped doing secondaries on the suggestion of this stackexchange.

Is there any particular reason for doing 4 week long primaries instead of two week long primaries?

I just made two batches from MoreBeer (my LHBS) and I was told that there should never be a reason to do most ales for longer than 2 weeks before bottling.

1 Answer 1


They're trying to make one simple, common set of instructions that satisfy both a large range of beers as well as a huge variability in customers, across the dimensions primarily of: inherent yeast performance, yeast health, lag time, fermentation temperature and adherence to instructions/technique, including a comfortable margin of "safety".

In short: they're very general purpose, boilerplate instructions.

You're starting to get to the point you understand the process independent of those instructions … it's not like NB extract has an owner's manual that's unique from MoreBeer extract, or the wort you'll get from all-grain, or whatever.

Go by gravity, not time; most beers (including above 1.050) will be done inside of 2 weeks. As you've learned, secondary is unnecessary without extended aging. Find a process that works for your tools/time/schedule, and go from there.

Na Zdrowie!

  • 1
    Some brewers say "let the beer make the schedule". That's the case here - some beers simply need longer to ferment out and clean up.
    – mdma
    Oct 3, 2013 at 12:00

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.