Hot answers tagged off-flavor
It's certainly possible - a starter is only fermented to completion, but not conditioned, so byproducts of fermentation, such as acetaldehyde (green apple) and acetolactate (which becomes diacetyl - butter/butterscotch) are still left in the beer. This have low taste thresholds (50ppb for diacetyl), so it doesn't take much for you to notice then. In a ...
The yeast odour can really only come from yeast. After 10-14 days in primary, be sure to leave the carboy to cold condition until the yeast have settled out and the wort looks fairly clear. The apple/cidery flavour does sound like acetaldehyde, which can come from to short conditioning period, oxidation, or contamination by acetic acid bacteria. The ...
Green apple aroma is typical of acetaldehyde. It could be the result of oxidation late in the fermentation or when bottling. Leaving it on the yeast helps, as it will reduce some or all of the acetaldehyde to ethanol. References: Pico Brewery, BJCP, BYO
This Wired article may help shed some light on wavelengths and bottle colour. http://www.wired.com/2013/03/physics-and-green-beer-bottles/ Amendment 1 Light in wavelengths of 350 nm to 520 nm (upper UV to mid-visible light) is known to cause skunky beer. Green bottles allow green light (520 nm to 550 nm) to pass through, whereas brown bottles (ranging ...
I've never tasted acetaminophen, but the 130g of black malt is probably your culprit. I made a stout with a similar amount, and the resulting beer was acrid and unpleasant. Aging mellowed it a bit, but it never turned into what I'd call a pleasant beer. For what it's worth, the only roasted malts I use in my stouts are roasted barley, and a small amount of ...
A long soak with a baking soda solution has worked for me in the past. I don't know what your measurements are, but I usually go of 1/3 to 1/2 cup into 6 gallons of hot water. Soak overnight, rinse and then another hot soak with my standard cleaner PBW (powdered brewery wash).
I have brewed dozens and dozens of rye beers...maybe more than most people, and I have never encountered that. I'd say that either you're extremely sensitive to something about rye or you're misinterpreting the cause.
I am going to answer this question myself, based on additional research. The list of columns in the question is complete. Also, the question has been edited to provide links for a source for each column. I will note that the Focus on Flavor column is often cited as a good study resource for the BJCP exam.
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible