Take the 2-minute tour ×
Homebrewing Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for dedicated home brewers and serious enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

When do you start your secondary fermentation? Some people wait until the bubbles of the wort stop completely, others leave the wort in the fist fermenter for 3-4 days and then move on to secondary fermentation, regardless of what the bubbles do. What are the advantages and disadvantages of each method?

share|improve this question

5 Answers 5

I wait until a day after the krausen has fallen back into the beer. You shouldn't leave it in the primary for more than 2 weeks.

PRO

Racking to a secondary can clean up a beer, and allow you time to condition the beer in bulk before bottling or kegging. It also will seperate the floculated yeast and trub giving you a cleaner beer in the end. You are also not rushed to bottle or keg it, since you can leave it in the secondary for a long time if you are busy. This also frees up your larger carboys for primary fermenting new beers.

CON

Increased risk of contamination durring racking. Make sure everything is sanitized. Increased contact with oxygen is also detrimental. I have a spare CO2 tank, that I purge my secondary with. This is not really neccessary, I just take comfort in it. You also need additional equipment, another carboy.

CON of not Racking

If you don't rack to a secondary you will probably get additional gunk in your bottles/kegs. If you don't rack to a secondary, after two or more weeks autolysis can occur and you will get some really funky (not the good funk) flavors. I have only tried this once, and noticed that the flavor was not very desirable.

I have sucessfully done this over a hundred times, and if the beer wasn't already contaminated then I have never had a problem. Hopped, Low pH, alcoholic liquid is pretty inhospitable environment for bugs.

EDIT

Please see John Palmers opinion. The best beer is Racked to a secondary, if the pros do it, so do I. Why be lazy when it's an easy step. Additionally if you use a smaller carboy for your secondary, with a small head space, the disolved C02 in the beer will be forced out durring racking, and force the much of the oxygen out, reducing contact.

http://www.howtobrew.com/section1/chapter8-2-3.html

http://www.howtobrew.com/section1/chapter8-5.html

http://www.howtobrew.com/section1/chapter8-4.html

share|improve this answer
3  
Palmer has changed his opinion since HTB was written. In the Ask the Experts section if the AHA website, John Palmer recently said this...."Therefore I, and Jamil and White Labs and Wyeast Labs, do not recommend racking to a secondary fermenter for ANY ale, except when conducting an actual second fermentation, such as adding fruit or souring. Racking to prevent autolysis is not necessary, and therefore the risk of oxidation is completely avoidable.". You can read more at homebrewersassociation.org/pages/lets-brew/ask-the-experts/… if you're an AHA member. –  Denny Conn Jun 11 '11 at 16:08
2  
Down-voted despite the otherwise solid info because you have this line in the start of your answer: "You shouldn't leave it in the primary for more than 2 weeks." Pretty much every experiment I've ever read about has confirmed that this is NOT the case anymore, or perhaps home brewers have been wrong about it all along. –  Graham Jun 13 '11 at 12:29

I tend to completely ferment out in primary before moving my beer to 'secondary'. I ferment in primary for 14-21 days almost always. I crash cool the primary for the final 5-7 days of that total primary time. Then I rack to keg.

I think most people can agree that a secondary ferment is not a ferment, its just another conditioning step in the process.

Minus the cooling step, people who put beer in kegs out of primary (myself included), or probrewers using a bright tank are doing the same thing as "using a secondary"; putting fermented beer in another container to sit for a while.
So while many of us say we don't secondary, we all do somewhat the same post primary conditioning step but using a second vessel to condition the beer or clear the beer. Its just that in the case of keggers we can serve out of the same vessle.

(In reality, I have an extra corny keg that I have trimmed the dip tube off about 3 inches. I use that keg as my "bright beer tank". Then use a jumper set up to push the beeer to a serving keg after that)

share|improve this answer

I don't rack to secondary unless I'm adding something (fruit, hops, spices) or aging (barleywine, etc). The risk of introducing bacteria is too great for me.

For most of my beer I leave the beer in the primary for 2 weeks which clears up the beer as much as I need. But, for those beers that need extra time to clarify I leave the beer in there longer.

I believe you can definitely leave your beer on the yeast cake for longer than 2 weeks, and I'm not alone. I stopped racking to secondary when I started listening to Jamil Zainasheff on Brew Strong. He claims the 2 week autolysis is a myth.

share|improve this answer
    
When you say that the risk of introducing bacteria is too great for you, do you mean that the risk is higher for you than for others, or that you perceive the risk, in general, to be too great? It's kind of hard to infect a beer unless you're working in a dirty environment. Not impossible, just not exactly guaranteed to happen. –  JackSmith Jan 21 '10 at 18:51
    
There's a risk, but it is a very small risk. Just use good sanitation practices and there should be no problem at all. –  Tim Weber Jan 21 '10 at 18:55
    
What I mean is that I view the risk (in general) of more equipment coming in contact with the beer to be greater than the risk of autolysis. –  sgwill Jan 21 '10 at 19:07

Read the answers to this question: What's the difference between primary & secondary fermentation?

I am an advocate of not racking to secondary. To answer your question:

Advantages

(of not racking)

  • Reduced risk of infection
  • Don't need as many vessels
  • More time for trub to settle (racking can disturb the trub if you have to move your fermenter)

Disadvantages

  • Risk of autolysis (low IMO)
  • You don't get to "play" with your beer

Bonus

I do not rack to secondary and still get very clear beer. After kegging I cool the beer to the low 30's F for a week or so to brighten. Crash cooling drops a lot of protein out of suspension. The first pull is pretty goopy, but the rest of the keg is pretty clear.

Pro brewers do this in a separate tank called a brite tank.

If you bottle you can get the same effect by racking to your bottling bucket, sealing that up and crash cooling it for a week in the bucket. Be very careful moving it, or bottle straight out of the fridge.

share|improve this answer
1  
Minus the cooling step, people who put beer in kegs out of primary (myself included), or probrewers using a bright tank are doing the same thing as "using a secondary"; putting fermented beer in another container to sit for a while. So while I say, I don't do a secondary....I (and we) actually do. –  brewchez Jan 21 '10 at 15:53

My name is Joseph and I have been making wine for about 50 years. It has become a tradition being passed down from generation to generation. I have always made good wine and I can't remember spoiling a batch but I must have. It happens to all wine makers even the pros. Lately I started to brew beer and I have made about 6 batches of Coopers home brew. I have always used a seconday fermenter to keep the product as clear and clean from sedament as I could. I am a clean freak and sanitize everything I touch even the scooper when I check out the brew with the hydrometer. So far my son after trying my first brew told me he would not purchase another case of beer from the beer store unless he was hard up. After adding up the figures that I spent on the brew he told me Dad I can't believe it. Here I am drinking a tall boy for 50 cents a bottle opposed to 2.35 a Bottle and your beer tastes greater. I feel that if you have achieved the success you wanted why chance another procedure. You can only get so much out of what you got so why fix it if it's not broke. Keep all your equipment sanitized and also your hands and you should always have some good success. Thank you. I find all of your comments most desirable and I have learned some knowledgable things reading this site. Take care.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.